TD 1
ARTSDESK PLACEHOLDERS The Politics of Place addre
sses how photographers have engaged with one of the defining obsessions of our national life, the notion of place. In the decades on either side of the fin de siécle, it was an open question whether photography could be considered an art. The uncertainty about photography’s status was motivated by the nature of the equipment that produces the image; what troubled the sceptics was the thorny issue of artistic autonomy. Who, or more appositely what, was actually responsible for the image under review? In the minds of many an art critic, the photograph – and later, the film-still – was the product of a merely mechanical recording and was excluded a priori from the domain of art. It was claimed that a work of art is not the result of unsentient, automatic processes, as though art could be created by machinery on the factory floor; each artwork involves feeling, intention, emotion and implicit meaning. The thinking behind this early scepticism, which was famously revived in our era by the late Roger Scruton, is that the camera only records the visual appearance of objects – it is unable to represent anything about the artist’s psychological state. This argument floated around in the back of my mind as I walked through the new exhibition at Photo Museum Ireland, because The Politics of Place is such an eloquent rejoinder to anyone that might still harbour a similar attitude towards photography. In the minds of those early sceptics, in the interaction between photographer and their environment, the product could only be classified as ‘landscape photography’. The principle of this exhibition, 48 however, is to address “how photographers have engaged with one of the defining obsessions of our national life, the notion of place.” The artists meditate on the meaning of place “as a way of speaking to and about national identity, the spaces and the landscapes we share, the ground that we hold in common and the boundaries that divide us.” That is, as distinct from the soil and brick viewed by the lens, over and beyond landscape, stands the concept of placehood. By expressing a unique sense of place, these photographs address “the profound changes that have reshaped Irish society over the last four decades, from the decline of the church to the impact of globalisation, through to ongoing crises around housing, migration, and the environment.” As the curatorial material suggests, the approaches that are explored here, though all index the concept of placehood, are wide-ranging and diverse. For instance, David Farrell’s work investigates the meaning of place from the perspective of political violence. Farrell is preoccupied by a subset of the victims of sectarian violence in Northern Ireland, known as ‘the Disappeared’. This group of 16 people were murdered by Republican paramilitaries at various stages throughout the Troubles and secretly buried. Their fates were suspected, but no organisation took responsibility or explained their involvement for decades. All of the Disappeared were Catholics, and one was a woman; Jean McConville, mother of ten. The artist has been documenting the sites where these bodies were exhumed since 1999, in the aftermath of extensive efforts on behalf of local police forces to discover the remains. The photographs were selected from Farrell’s Small Acts of Memory series (2009-2010), featuring an earthy field, dissected by digging equipment. Chestnut browns, charcoal greys and vivid ochres predominate in these compositions, and the images of displaced soil and forest clearings have a ritualistic quality. Farrell’s work memorialises the “intangible presence of absence,” to use his poetic phrase, representing a trauma that has settled deep into the marrow of the landscape. Death hovers in the background of other artworks too. In 2013, Miriam O’Connor’s brother passed away and the responsibility for the family farm, which had been in his care until then, fell on the shoulders of Miriam and her sister. The selection of photographs in this exhibition were taken from a series called Tomorrow is Sunday, composed by O’Connor between 2014 and 2020. Although the impetus for O’Connor’s project also involved death, her work is in many ways dissimilar to Farrell’s; whereas Farrell’s imagery compresses time so that the layers of soil and plant-life analogise the longlasting impact of the disappearances, O’Connor’s work conveys a more fleeting temporality. These are moments, fragments of memory, evocative of a single word, a passing cloud, a stray emotion that burned brightly and then withdrew. Her fragments Aoife McCloughlin, Gleanings